+44 (0) 1865 952700 |
Press enquiries
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


Home/The carbon price thaw: Post-freeze future of the GB carbon price

The carbon price thaw: Post-freeze future of the GB carbon price

In the upcoming November Autumn Budget, the Treasury will decide the future of carbon pricing in GB. Following last year’s “non-announcement” confirming the existing freeze of Carbon Price Support until 2020/21, and the Spring Budget’s teaser revealing plans to scrap CPS and replace it with a total carbon price target, Chancellor Philip Hammond’s third statement on the matter is expected to finally lay out a concrete trajectory for CO2 ­prices beyond 2021.

The mixed track record of CPS to date shows just how consequential the decision can be. On one hand, the policy is rightly credited with coal’s demise and the resulting drop in emissions in the face of weak EU ETS – 13 GW of coal capacity exited the market since its introduction in 2013. On the other hand, despite the original intention, CPS failed to incentivise low-carbon investment, owing to insufficient level and lack of long-term certainty.

The impact of November announcement will be equally significant, and goes to the heart of the policy trilemma. Setting out a steep, long-term carbon price trajectory could boost decarbonisation by precipitating deployment of unsubsidised renewables, but would also have significant impact on consumer pockets and could potentially threaten security of supply, if intermittent wind and solar proliferate excessively. Conversely, a sudden drop in carbon pricing could reverse coal-to-gas switching and hit ROC-based renewables, and – if existing nuclear were to retire early – also cause security of supply problems. On the plus side, it would bring GB wholesale prices closer to the European levels.

To complicate things further, the Treasury’s decision does not take place in isolation. First, Brexit could see the UK crashing out of EU-ETS in 2019, leading to a temporary increase in coal production as total carbon price drops. Second, if European allowances’ price fails to recover despite reforms, maintaining the current differential may prove increasingly politically difficult, and – with interconnection set to boom – lead to great disadvantage of domestic generators. Finally, interactions with other policies have to be considered – once coal plants close by mandate in 2025, the rationale for high carbon price may weaken drastically.

In this study, we explore potential carbon price scenarios and their consequences for market participants and policy goals; and address the following questions:

  • Which CPS trajectories seem likely and what are key considerations around them?
  • What are the consequences for policy makers and the energy policy trilemma?
  • What are implications for different technologies and market participants?
View Report

Our subscription services

Our subscription service provides you with long-term market forecasts, strategic insight reports, interactive client forums and access to our market data and analytics platform.

Interested? Please sign up to receive our complimentary monthly summary reports via email. Simply tick which reports you would like to receive. Please indicate your consent in the box provided and view our privacy policy.

If you would like further information on a particular subscription service or report please enter further information in the box provided.



  • Please find our privacy policy here

  • In October 2014, EU leaders agreed on common climate and energy targets for 2030. These included a 40% reduction in GHG emissions relative to 1990 levels, along with targets for renewables deployment and energy efficiency. However, Europe’s main decarbonisation instrument, the EU ETS Phase III, is well out of step with her stated ambitions. The 20% reduction in GHG emissions by 2020 should easily be achieved. However, the 2030 target requires credible commitment to much more stringent policies, particularly in power, where the economics dictate much of the emission reduction burden should be borne.

    Read More
  • Natural gas markets are growing fast on a global level, with more players, increasingly complex rules and mechanisms, and rising global connectivity. In this global context, Europe sits in a unique position, with an escalating import dependency and an ever growing number of suppliers. Increasingly difficult upstream financing, highly political infrastructure developments, and the intricate evolution of gas-for-power demand will drive the future of the European gas market.

    Read More
  • Commodity prices drive the size and structure of the energy industry perhaps more than any other factor. Long-term commodity price expectations have fallen dramatically across the energy market, and strategies and policies are evolving consistent with these new beliefs. More than $200 billion worth of oil and natural gas assets are currently for sale globally. Coal-to-gas switching in power, which becomes more attractive with falling commodity prices, is firmly on the political agenda in Europe and the US.

    Read More